To eat crow means to be forced to admit a humiliating mistake, retract a strongly held statement, or suffer public shame and defeat after being proven completely wrong.
Also: Eating crow, eat boiled crow, eat a plate of crow, make someone eat crow
Origin & History of “Eat Crow”
The idiom originated in mid-19th-century American vernacular, popularized not by military legend, but through folk humor and partisan newspaper rivalries:
The Literal Metaphor: Inedible Meat
Crows are scavenging, carnivorous birds. Because of their diet and muscular build, crow meat is notoriously dark, tough, pungent, and foul-tasting. While people ate crow during extreme famines, it was widely considered repulsive. Forcing someone to swallow crow became the ultimate physical metaphor for being forced to “swallow” words you desperately regret saying.
The 1850 Humor Story: “I Don’t Hanker After It”
One of the earliest documented appearances comes from an 1850 issue of the Saturday Evening Post in a tall tale titled “Can You Eat Crow?” In the story, a character named Isaac is tricked into eating a cooked crow on a bet. As he chews through the foul meat with mounting nausea, he famously declares: “Yes, I kin eat crow… but I’ll be darned if I hanker after it!” The punchline became a popular catchphrase in 19th-century America to describe enduring something deeply unpleasant with reluctant resignation.
The 1870s Partisan Press: “Eating Boiled Crow”
During the 1870s, the phrase exploded across American journalism. 19th-century newspapers were fiercely partisan, and editors frequently wrote brutal attacks on rival political candidates. When an editor was forced to retract a false report, or when their party nominated a candidate the paper had spent months condemning, rival editors mocked them for having to “eat boiled crow.” The addition of “boiled” simply heightened the visceral disgust of the retraction.
The War of 1812 Myth
A popular folklore story claims that during an armistice in the War of 1812, an American soldier shot a crow behind British lines, was forced at gunpoint by a British officer to eat a bite of it, and then turned the gun on the officer and made him eat the rest. While entertaining, this story only appeared in print decades after the war as a fictional piece of humorous satire, rather than the historical origin of the idiom.
“If You Have to Eat Crow, Eat It While It’s Hot”
A famous 20th-century political variation—attributed to Alben W. Barkley (Vice President under Harry Truman) advises: “If you have to eat crow, eat it while it’s hot.”
Barkley’s point was meant to be sound tactical advice. If a politician or public figure makes a catastrophic blunder, it is far better to admit the mistake immediately and take the humiliation quickly while the news is breaking, rather than letting it linger and rot into an ongoing scandal.
Sentence Examples
- “After predicting a blowout victory all week, the sports analyst had to eat crow on national television when his team lost by thirty points.”
- “The board insisted the new policy would fail, but after profits doubled, they were forced to eat a plate of crow.”
- “I swore I’d never buy a minivan, but with three kids and two dogs, I’m ready to eat some crow.”
- “When the leaked documents proved the story was true, the newspaper’s chief editor had to eat boiled crow and print a front-page apology.”
Video Presentation
Similar and Related Expressions
- Eat Humble Pie: To be forced to apologize, act submissively, or acknowledge humiliating defeat (derived from deer organ “umbles”).
- Eat Your Words: To be forced to admit that what you previously said was wrong.
- Back down: To withdraw a claim, demand, or aggressive position.
- Swallow One’s Pride: To accept humiliation or defeat in order to move forward.